U.S. Education Department pings states, schools to set policies on cellphone use • Utah News Dispatch
Written by Black Hot Fire Network on December 3, 2024
WASHINGTON — The U.S. Education Department called on every state, school and district on Tuesday to adopt policies on cellphone use in schools.
The department asks schools to have well-thought-out policies on the matter, but does not dictate exactly what those policies should be. An accompanying resource for schools notes the risk social media can pose to students’ mental health.
“In this digital age, every elementary, middle, and high school should have a clear, consistent, and research-informed policy to guide the use of phones and personal devices in school,” U.S Education Secretary Miguel Cardona said in a written statement.
“The evidence makes clear: there is no one-size-fits-all policy,” Cardona added, noting that “different school communities have different needs, and the nuances of this issue demand that local voices — parents, educators, and students — inform local decisions around the use of personal devices in school.”
The department acknowledged the role cellphones can play in keeping parents connected to their kids, especially in emergency situations, while also highlighting the increasing evidence on the harms social media can have on youth mental health, such as sleep deprivation and depression.
Increasing state policies
An increasing number of states and school districts have enacted policies either prohibiting or restricting students from using their cellphones in the classrooms.
Across the country, schools and districts continue to grapple with how to deal with kids’ cellphone use, and more than half of all states have sought to ban or restrict cellphone use in classrooms.
As of early November, at least eight states have passed statewide policies that either limit or prohibit cellphone use in the classrooms, according to KFF.
That includes California, Florida, Indiana, Louisiana, Ohio, South Carolina and Virginia. A Minnesota law forces schools to adopt a policy on cellphone use by March 2025.
A handful of other states’ education departments have issued policy recommendations or pilot programs, while lawmakers in several more have introduced statewide legislation regarding cellphone use.
The guidance from the U.S. Education Department coincides with the release of a resource for education officials and local communities on adopting cellphone use policies.
In the playbook, Cardona points to U.S. Surgeon General Dr. Vivek Murthy’s public warning in 2023 on social media’s effects on youth mental health.
Murthy warns: “More research is needed to fully understand the impact of social media; however, the current body of evidence indicates that while social media may have benefits for some children and adolescents, there are ample indicators that social media can also have a profound risk of harm to the mental health and well-being of children and adolescents.”
Last updated 12:47 p.m., Dec. 3, 2024
Utah lawmakers may consider pulling phones from schools in 2025
More than three months before the U.S. Department of Education’s call to develop policies around cellphones in schools, efforts were already in motion in Utah to keep digital devices out of classes.
As students headed back to school in August, South Jordan Republican Sen. Lincoln Fillmore and Rep. Douglas Welton, R-Payson, revealed a draft bill bound for the 2025 legislative session that would establish a statewide cellphone and smartwatch ban as a default for school districts, citing substantial distractions for students.
That was after Gov. Spencer Cox in January, ahead of the 2024 legislative session, urged schools to adopt cellphone-free policies out of concern for the toll social media is taking on youth mental health.
Under the bill, districts would retain the ability to opt out of the prohibition and instead adopt policies to allow smart devices in their schools.
“We’ve preserved local control, but we’re recognizing that in the time since cellphones, and especially smartphones, became ubiquitous in schools, we have learned so much about their impact on students and their impact on the learning process that we need a reset,” Fillmore said in an Aug. 26 news conference at Granger High School in West Valley City.
The bill would also appropriate a one-time payment of $4.8 million from the Public Education Economic Stabilization Restricted Account to create a grant that schools could use to research cellphone programs and to purchase equipment such as magnetic locking pouches that students at Granger High are using to keep their devices.
