Categories: USA News

Sotomayor in Philadelphia warns of eroding legal norms

Sotomayor pointed to Trump v. Slaughter as another example of the court undermining such norms. The decision overturned a 1935 precedent that limited the president’s authority to remove members of the Federal Trade Commission.

The ruling was based on the unitary executive theory, which posits that the president has sole and absolute power over the executive branch of government. Sotomayor called it a “legal theory on steroids that has just gone off the rails.”

The justice added that there were a number of cases she thought were decided properly, such as the court’s ruling that pushed back on the president’s tariffs and efforts to end birthright citizenship.

“There are things to be celebrated, and there’s no question that some rulings were the right rulings,” she said. “Were they all for the right reasons? I don’t know.”

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor speaks to former Judge David Tatel during the American Philosophical Society autumn general meeting in Philadelphia Friday. (Photo courtesy of American Philosophical Society.)

However, she also criticized the recent trend of emergency dockets in which the Supreme Court makes decisions in cases that have not been heard by lower courts.

“That is bad for us as a court, because we are making decisions without being assured that all of the relevant legal questions have been actually fully explored,” she said. “It is important before the court is making a final decision that we are fully informed, and we’re not being fully informed and we’re making rushed judgments.”

The American Philosophical Society, which Franklin founded in 1743, promotes knowledge in the humanities and natural sciences. The session with Sotomayor was part of the organization’s three-day autumn general meeting, during which leading researchers presented findings on history, economics and neuroscience.

The Benjamin Franklin Medal was established in 1906 and has been awarded to prominent leaders in their fields, such as physicist Marie Curie, geneticist Barbara McClintock, and scientists Francis Crick and James Watson. Sotomayor received the medal recognizing distinguished public service, which has been previously awarded to Nelson Mandela, the South African Black activist who spent 27 years in prison for opposing the region’s apartheid system of racial segregation, former U.K. Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher and Bryan Stevenson, the founder and executive director of the Equal Justice Initiative.

Sotomayor spoke in conversation with David S. Tatel, a retired civil rights lawyer and appellate judge.

Black Hot Fire Network Team

BHFN Editorial Team covers breaking news, culture, and global developments impacting Black America, Africa, Kenya, and the African diaspora. Focused on timely reporting and community-driven perspectives, the team delivers news, analysis, and stories that inform, connect, and amplify diverse voices.

Share
Published by
Black Hot Fire Network Team

Recent Posts

NaTHNaC – Ebola disease

The outbreak remains a public health emergency of international concern On 5 May 2026,…

54 minutes ago

AJK Chief Justice Calls for Global Legislation on AI Use in Warfare

AJK Chief Justice Calls for Global Legislation on…

3 hours ago

Why Nairobi-only AFCON hosting could cost Kenya a wider tourism windfall – K24 Digital

Kenya’s hopes of turning the 2027 Africa Cup of Nations into a nationwide tourism bonanza…

4 hours ago

25 migrants deported from US arrive in Liberia

Twenty-five migrants deported from the United States have arrived in west Africa, a commission in…

4 hours ago

JAY-Z Fade To Black Free on YouTube: 2004 Concert Film

HomeMusicHip-HopJAY-Z Puts Fade To Black, His 2004 Concert Film, on YouTube for Free By Miles…

4 hours ago