Africa currently faces a profound deficit in its health workforce, bearing over 20% of the global disease burden while possessing only 3% of the world’s human resources for health (HRH). The continent’s average density stands at 1.55 physicians, nurses, and midwives per 1,000 people, a figure substantially lower than the World Health Organization’s threshold of 4.45 required to attain universal health coverage. In this context, a recently published scoping review has synthesized evidence from 65 peer-reviewed and gray literature sources published between 2010 and 2024 to identify the primary drivers behind the out-migration of Africa-born medical professionals and the potential policies to manage these movements. Utilizing the Arksey and O’Malley framework along with the PRISMA-ScR checklist, the researchers sought to understand the economic, professional, social, and political dynamics that push health workers out of African nations and the corresponding pull factors in destination countries. By applying the WHO’s Global Strategy on Human Resources for Health Workforce 2030 policy levers framework, the study provides a comprehensive assessment of how national, regional, and global bodies are currently attempting to mitigate brain drain while respecting individual professional mobility and fostering health system resilience.
The review identifies a multifaceted range of push factors that motivate Africa-born health professionals to seek employment outside the continent. Among these, inadequate financial remuneration in source countries is a dominant economic driver, often exacerbated by limited fiscal space in national budgets that prevents the effective employment and deployment of health graduates. Professionally, workers cited poor work environments, a lack of infrastructure, limited opportunities for continuing medical and postgraduate education, and an overall scarcity of research funding as primary obstacles to their career progression within Africa. These professional frustrations are often compounded by social and political realities. Many practitioners reported poor living conditions, a lack of respect or appreciation from national governments, and the disruptive influence of war, conflict, and political instability as decisive factors in their decision to emigrate. In contrast, destination countries—typically high-income nations—exert a significant pull, offering better remuneration, superior work environments, and clearer pathways for professional advancement and social mobility. These destination countries often benefit from the subsidization of initial medical training by the source African nations, further perpetuating the cycle of skilled worker loss.
Interestingly, the study sheds light on the drivers of return and circular migration, revealing that the decision-making process for health workers is not exclusively based on economic gain. Many Africa-born health professionals who migrated abroad later returned to their source countries or engaged in circular migration due to factors like the high cost of living in destination countries, limited family support, and experiences of racism or professional discrimination. A common phenomenon reported in destination settings is deskilling, where highly qualified African physicians or nurses are restricted from full registration or relegated to menial roles for which they are overqualified. Driven by a desire for impact, a sense of patriotism, and the opportunity to work in underserved areas, some professionals return home to contribute their expertise. Furthermore, improved political stability in certain African nations and the development of circular migration arrangements, such as dual citizenship or permanent residency status that allow for easier border crossing, have become increasingly relevant factors in encouraging return flows to the continent.
To address these systemic challenges, the researchers mapped various policies using the WHO HRH policy levers framework, categorized by their national, regional, and global scope. At the national level, source countries have implemented diverse strategies to improve HRH retention. These include financial incentives such as increased salaries and the introduction of policies like South Africa’s Occupation Specific Dispensation (OSD), which aimed to align public sector pay with competitive market rates. Other countries have explored allowing dual practice, or moonlighting, to enable workers to supplement their incomes, as well as providing more flexible working hours and targeted professional development opportunities. Additionally, some nations have implemented compulsory service requirements prior to allowing international exit, though the effectiveness and ethical implications of such mandates remain points of debate within the broader discourse on individual rights and workforce management.
A notable innovation highlighted in the review is the emergence of formal repatriation policies, which were not part of the original WHO framework but have become essential in current practice. These include short-term returns, often lasting less than a year, which allow for activities such as remote assistance, fundraising, advocacy, and direct clinical or teaching support. Long-term repatriation involves the permanent return of health workers, bringing back resources and international expertise. Circular migration, a hybrid model, is increasingly viewed as a viable middle ground, particularly for diaspora professionals with permanent residence in destination countries, as it provides the flexibility to maintain professional ties while spending significant portions of the year serving health systems back in Africa. These programs, however, require careful implementation, as high-cost initiatives that fail to address the underlying political and economic drivers of migration in the home country often struggle to achieve sustainable retention.
Regional initiatives are playing an increasingly critical role in the management of these migration trends, particularly through the involvement of the Africa Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (Africa CDC). The study highlights the potential for regional bodies to harmonize training, licensure, and registration processes, effectively lowering the technical and regulatory barriers that discourage health workers from returning to their home countries. By expanding the use of tools like the AVoHC Net, which facilitates the rapid deployment of a standby workforce for emergencies, regional institutions can create better-defined pathways for the diaspora to contribute during crises. The authors suggest that the Africa CDC should develop a dedicated concierge service to assist returning professionals by translating credentials, matching their specific skills with domestic needs, and navigating bureaucratic obstacles. Such regional harmonization is seen as a key step in preventing a disjointed patchwork of bilateral agreements from exacerbating the existing inequities between African health systems.
Global actors, including the WHO and the World Trade Organization (WTO), also hold significant, though currently underutilized, potential in this arena. The WHO Global Code of Practice on the International Recruitment of Health Personnel provides a foundational set of standards designed to discourage unethical recruitment and promote bilateral reciprocity. However, the study confirms that the voluntary nature of the Code limits its real-world impact, as it lacks strong governance, financing, and robust enforcement mechanisms. Integrating these standards into national laws and regulatory frameworks is frequently identified as a priority for improving the effectiveness of the Code. Meanwhile, the WTO, through trade agreements such as the General Agreement on Trade Services (GATS), could theoretically be leveraged to enforce fair compensation and protection for health workers, yet its focus remains primarily on the liberalization of trade rather than the regulation of permanent labor markets or ethical health worker protections.
The role of the private sector and international funding bodies remains an underexplored but potentially vital component of any comprehensive migration strategy. While the private sector has participated in some countries in HRH training and the support of dual practice arrangements, its potential to aid in service delivery and infrastructure development in underserved areas is largely untapped. Public-private partnerships could incentivize investment in rural regions, potentially creating the kind of work environment that encourages health workers to stay. Furthermore, major global health institutions such as the Global Fund and the Gates Foundation, which have already made significant investments in workforce development and training, are well-positioned to advocate for deeper policy reform. By focusing on improving working conditions and strengthening the overall health infrastructure in source countries, these entities can help transform African health sectors into viable, long-term options for trained medical personnel.
Despite its comprehensive scope, the study acknowledges several limitations inherent to its design. As a scoping review focusing on English-language literature, it may have introduced a degree of geographic bias, although the team believes the inclusion of pan-African research adequately accounts for diverse perspectives. Being a scoping review rather than a systematic review means it did not rank the relative importance of specific drivers or measure the comparative effectiveness of different policy interventions. The use of a single reviewer for the initial screening and full-text selection, while consensus-based, carries a potential risk of selection bias. Furthermore, the analysis did not explicitly explore the complex interdependencies between various drivers of migration, nor did it cover the significant dynamics of intra-Africa migration, which would require separate study to fully understand the impact of regional mobility on health system capacity.
Looking ahead, the researchers warn that changes in international funding, such as the recent shifts in US global health investment, could intensify current migration pressures. As resource constraints mount, the need for multilevel, collaborative efforts—spanning government, regional bodies, and the private sector—becomes more urgent. The study concludes that while there is no single solution, a combination of innovative repatriation models, better regional harmonization, and stricter adherence to ethical recruitment standards offers the best pathway forward. By transitioning from reactive measures to proactive, systemic policies that address the fundamental economic and political determinants of migration, African countries may better protect their human resources for health, ultimately strengthening the resilience of their health systems against both routine demands and future public health emergencies.
Subject of Research: The study analyzes drivers of and policy frameworks for managing the international migration of Africa-born health personnel, focusing on retention and return migration strategies.
Article Title: International migration of Africa-born health workers: a scoping review of drivers and policies, 2010–2024
Article References: Wamuti, B., Pate, M. A., & Justman, J. E. (2026). International migration of Africa-born health workers: a scoping review of drivers and policies, 2010–2024. Human Resources for Health, 24(1), Article 47. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12960-026-01093-9
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s12960-026-01093-9
Keywords: Africa, health workforce, human resources for health, medical migration, brain drain, policy levers, push-pull theory, scoping review, health policy, return migration, circular migration, medical education, workforce retention, professional development, global health, health system resilience, Africa CDC, World Health Organization